NOTE: As a service to residents, the Board of Legislators provides this guide to area prices for home heating oil. 
This information is updated during the period from the fall through early spring.

Sort columns by clicking header below.

Company Name$/gal.Date PostedContact Info.Areas ServicedService
Type
All Time Fuel

3.55 (cash)

3.65 (credit)

02/27/2024

73 South 3rd Avenue
Mount Vernon, NY 10550
914-979-0416

Lower Westchester Full Service
Barrco Fuel LLC 3.40 (cash/credit) 02/15/2024 339 Mamaroneck Ave, Suite 339
White Plains NY
914-200-1224
Westchester and Putnam County N/A
Buy Rite Fuel Company

3.50 (cash/credit)

02/27/2024 1223 Lincoln Terrace
Peekskill, NY 10566
914-737-2200
www.buyritefuel.net
Northern Wstchtr. and Putnam County Full Service
Castle Fuel 3.50 02/27/2024 81 Charter Circle
Ossining, NY 10562
914-531-7100
www.castlefuel.com
   
Cheap Oil

3.50 (cash)
3.60 (credit)

02/27/2024 14 Morrissey Drive
Lake Peekskill, NY 10537
845-628-8389
www.cheapoil.biz
Northern Wstchtr., Cortland,
Peekskill
Full Service
Chrysalis Fuel Inc. 3.50 (cash)
3.52 (credit)
02/27/2024 87 Sleigat Plass Rd
Poughkeepsie NY 12603
845-265-2002
www.chrysalisfuelinc.com
Northern Westchester, Putnam and Dutchess Counties N/A
Economy Fuel 3.59 (cash/credit) 02/27/2024

500 Highland Avenue
Peekskill, NY 10566
914-739-5590
www.economyfuelny.com

Wstchtr., Putnam C.O.D Only
Superior Fuel Oil Inc.

3.54 (cash/credit)

02/27/2024 1 Highland Industrial Park 
Peekskill, NY 10566 
914-930-8655 
www.superiorfueloilinc.com
Wstchtr., Putnam N/A
Supreme Oil 3.49 (cash/credit)

02/27/2024

75 S. Broadway
White Plains, NY 10601
914-893-4800
www.supremeoil.us

Westchester Full Service

NOTES:

- As prices may change daily, please call company for current pricing.

- Not responsible for any errors or omissions in the content on this webpage.

*Full Service Fuel Oil Companies, in most cases not only sell fuel oil but also offer a wide range of services, including automatic deliveries, 24 hour emergency service, 30 day credit, “capped” or “fixed” price programs, budget plans, equipment maintenance, service agreements and installation of new equipment, such as boilers, furnaces, burners, hot water heaters, etc.